How to Deal with Regret: Practical Tips for Moving Past ‘What If’ Scenarios

 » Physical and mental well-being

How to Deal with Regret: Practical Tips for Moving Past ‘What If’ Scenarios

---

Introduction

Life is full of choices and paths not taken, so it’s unsurprising that people sometimes feel regret over decisions made or opportunities missed ¹. Regret, defined as an aversive emotion focused on the belief that past events could have been changed for a better outcome, can be incredibly painful ^1 2. While rooted in feelings like disappointment, guilt or remorse, dwelling on regret can negatively impact mental health by increasing stress, anxiety and emotional distress ².

However, regret doesn’t have to weigh you down indefinitely. This article explores practical strategies for how to deal with regret in a healthy way, overcome rumination on the past, and use self-reflection as motivation for positive change ^1 2. You’ll learn coping mechanisms to manage feelings of guilt and shame, as well as techniques for developing acceptance and moving forward after tough decisions or perceived mistakes.

1. The Nature of Regret

Simply put, regret is the feeling that we may have had something more positive now if we had made a different decision in the past, feeling sorry for misfortunes, or the disappointment over something we’ve failed to do ³. Largely, people feel regret more intensely for things they haven’t done (missed opportunities) than for things they did do (or decisions they made) ^3 4.

Defining Regret

Regret is an emotion that makes us feel worse, not better. It’s triggered when we think of something from our past and wish we had done something differently, taken an action, or not taken an action ⁵. Years of working in the behavioral sciences have given researchers a more positive frame for viewing regret than the traditionally negative one ⁵. However, reframing the feeling doesn’t make one immune to it.

Types of Regret – Action vs. Inaction

There are two main types of regret – regrets of action and regrets of inaction ^5 4. Regrets of action stem from things we did, while regrets of inaction are about the opportunities we didn’t pursue or actions we didn’t take.

A key demographic difference is that when people are young, say in their 20s, they have roughly equal numbers of action and inaction regrets ⁵. However, as we age into our 30s, 40s, 50s, and beyond, inaction regrets become twice as prevalent as action regrets ⁵. As we get older, the regrets about what we didn’t do tend to stick with us more than the regrets over things we did.

Regret, like all difficult emotions, is neither intrinsically good nor bad ³. It’s the actions we choose following the emotion that make a difference to our long-term well-being. For example, regretting not getting a raise last year could motivate someone to work harder this year, making regret a positive driving force ³. However, ruminating endlessly on that regret prevents moving forward productively ³.

2. Dealing with Regret

Dealing with regret can be a challenging process, but there are several strategies that can help you move forward in a healthy way.

Reflect and Move On

Reflecting on your regrets is a crucial first step. Acknowledge the feelings of regret, disappointment, or guilt you’re experiencing ¹². However, it’s important not to get stuck in a cycle of rumination or obsessive thinking about the past ⁶. Instead, try to approach your regrets with self-compassion and a willingness to learn from the experience ⁶.

When you find yourself dwelling on regrets, shift your attention to the present moment by focusing on your breath or engaging in a mindfulness exercise ⁶. This can help you break free from negative thought patterns and create space for more constructive reflection.

Reframe Your Thinking

Reframing your perspective on regret can be a powerful tool for moving forward. Instead of viewing regret as a purely negative emotion, try to see it as an opportunity for personal growth and self-improvement ⁶.

Ask yourself what lessons you can learn from the experience and how you can use those insights to make better choices in the future ⁶⁶. Identify any positive outcomes or silver linings that may have emerged from the situation you regret ⁶.

It’s also important to recognize that you cannot change the past, but you can control how you respond to it in the present moment ⁶. Remind yourself that dwelling on regret is unproductive and that you have the power to choose a more positive mindset.

Forgive Yourself

Self-forgiveness is a crucial step in the process of dealing with regret ⁷⁸. It involves acknowledging your mistakes, taking responsibility for your actions, and then consciously choosing to let go of self-blame and negative emotions ⁷.

To foster self-forgiveness, try to reaffirm your worth and build up positive feelings about yourself ⁸. Treat yourself with the same compassion and kindness you would extend to a friend in a similar situation ⁷.

Remember that self-forgiveness is not about excusing or minimizing your actions; it’s about recognizing that holding onto regret and self-resentment is no longer serving you ⁷⁸. By practicing self-forgiveness, you can free yourself from the burden of regret and move forward with a renewed sense of purpose.

Apologize and Make Amends

If your regrets involve causing harm to others, it’s important to take steps to make amends ⁶⁷⁸. This can involve offering a sincere apology, acknowledging the pain you’ve caused, and expressing a genuine intention to change your behavior ⁹¹⁰.

Making amends may also involve taking concrete actions to repair the damage or harm caused, such as replacing damaged property or making restitution ⁹¹⁰. However, it’s important to recognize that the other person may not be ready to forgive you, and you must respect their decision ⁶.

The process of making amends is not about seeking forgiveness from others; it’s about taking responsibility for your actions and recommitting to your values ⁸. By taking these steps, you can begin to heal the wounds caused by your regrets and move forward with a clearer conscience.

3. Coping Mechanisms

Mindfulness and Meditation

Mindfulness and meditation can be powerful tools for coping with regret. They encourage focusing on the present moment instead of getting caught up in ruminating over the past ¹¹. Through mindfulness practices like breath awareness, individuals can cultivate an open and accepting attitude towards their emotions, including regret ¹². This can help prevent resistance or avoidance, which often leads to more suffering ¹².

One effective mindfulness exercise is a guided meditation for regret ¹². It involves acknowledging and observing the feelings of regret with gentle curiosity, without judgment or analysis ¹². The practice emphasizes accepting the present moment, including any emotions that arise, rather than suppressing or resisting them ¹². Counting breaths or focusing on the physical sensations of breathing can help steady the mind and prevent getting lost in thoughts or stories about the regret ¹².

Journaling

Journaling is another valuable coping mechanism for dealing with regret. The act of putting thoughts and feelings into words can help process and express emotions, leading to increased awareness and emotional regulation ¹³. Writing about a regretful experience can break the cycle of obsessive thinking and brooding, providing a sense of release ¹³.

Expressive writing, where individuals write about their deepest thoughts and feelings surrounding a stressful or emotional event, has been shown to have particular benefits for mental well-being ¹³. Studies have found that expressive writing can reduce anxiety, create emotional awareness, and even promote physical healing ¹³.

When journaling about regret, it’s important to approach the practice with self-compassion and without judgment ¹³. There are no strict rules; individuals can write in whatever format feels most natural, whether it’s lists, poetry, letters, or drawings ¹³. The key is to create a consistent habit and allow emotions to flow freely onto the page ¹³.

Talking to a Therapist

For some individuals, coping with regret may require the guidance and support of a mental health professional. Therapy can provide a safe and non-judgmental space to work through feelings of regret, process emotions, and develop healthy coping strategies ¹¹.

A therapist can help individuals practice techniques like cognitive reframing, which involves changing one’s mindset and perspective on a situation ¹. This approach can foster self-compassion, validate emotions, and challenge cognitive distortions that contribute to negative thinking patterns ¹.

Therapy can also assist individuals in turning regrets into opportunities for growth and change ¹. By exploring what could have been done differently and reframing regrets as learning experiences, individuals can develop the skills and mindset needed to make better choices in the future ¹.

If you’re considering therapy but aren’t sure where to start, resources like Psych Central’s guide to finding mental health support can be helpful ¹¹. Additionally, there are many affordable online therapy options available ¹¹.

4. Turning Regret into Motivation

When harnessed skillfully, regret can increase the likelihood of psychological growth ⁶. Regret can prompt reflection on behavior, learning which actions work well and which don’t, ultimately leading to self-improvement in the long run ⁶. The emotional pang of regret can help understand the need for change and provide the push to follow through ⁶.

Setting Goals

Ask yourself: “Given what I’ve regretted, what can I still do that aligns with who I want to be as a person?” ⁶ Jot down as many positive answers as possible, then create a plan to enact at least some of them ⁶. For example, someone regretting how they may have failed a deceased parent could honor their memory by regularly visiting their grave and writing a biography of their life, providing meaningful focus ⁶.

Regrets can elucidate what matters most and clarify personal values as a friend, partner, parent, child, or professional ⁶. Perhaps regretting harsh treatment of an employee highlights the importance of being a compassionate, supportive boss ⁶. Or regretting not spending enough quality time with children reveals valuing being a hands-on, available parent ⁶.

Some goals aligning with values could directly rectify regrets, like going to medical school in one’s 30s after regretting not doing so earlier, or rearranging a work schedule to see kids more ⁶. Even when it seems too late to pursue something, it may not be ⁶. However, sometimes the metaphorical ship has sailed, making specific goal fulfillment impossible, like illness preventing world travel ⁶. In those cases, pursue alternative goals serving the same values, such as watching travel documentaries and exploring one’s town as a tourist for the would-be world traveler ⁶.

Learning from Experience

Transforming regret into a learning experience paves the way toward self-forgiveness and healing ¹⁴. Build resilience by avoiding dwelling on regret and instead objectively considering options like a third-person narrator ¹⁴. Set goals prioritizing nurturing interpersonal connections, as loneliness carries health risks and relationship regrets often sting the most ¹⁴.

Regrets surrounding missed opportunities due to fear or busyness can be particularly painful ¹⁴. However, it’s easier to change course after taking action than recapturing missed moments ¹⁴. Life’s curveballs make the ability to bounce back, learn from mistakes, and keep moving forward crucial ¹⁴. Nurturing self-confidence and coping skills prepares for such moments ¹⁴.

Taking Positive Action

Regret serves an adaptive purpose – it can motivate avoiding repeating past mistakes by accepting them, understanding what happened, and integrating that experience into present self-awareness ¹⁵. Taking responsibility for mistakes prevents repeating them – regret’s purpose ¹⁵.

Painful experiences may ultimately be seen as important, guiding to self-acceptance of flaws ¹⁵. Regret illuminates a spectrum of emotions, from lamenting flaws to understanding and accepting them ¹⁵. Accept the past as unchangeable, make amends where possible, bring attention to the present, and create a better future through positive choices ¹⁶.

Reframe regrets as growth lessons shaping who you are today ¹⁶. Live those moments, accept scenarios thinking “If I could have, I would have, but I did my best/worst then” ¹⁶. Forgive yourself, vow to avoid repeating mistakes, apologize sincerely to those wronged, and repent through actions ¹⁶. Let go of what cannot be changed, live presently, work on future plans, and focus on positive memories ¹⁶.

Conclusion

Dealing with regret can undoubtedly be a challenging process, but it is crucial for personal growth and moving forward in life. By reflecting on our regrets with self-compassion, reframing our perspective, practicing forgiveness, and seeking support when needed, we can transform regret into a powerful motivator for positive change. Remember that regret is a natural human emotion, and it is how we respond to it that truly matters.

Ultimately, the path to overcoming regret lies in acknowledging our mistakes, learning from them, and using those lessons to make better choices in the future. By letting go of what cannot be changed and focusing our energy on the present moment and our goals, we can break free from the cycle of rumination and embrace a more fulfilling, purposeful life.

FAQs